I was perfect for the AL Central, when the Guardians overtook the Tigers for first with a strong finish. I would have been perfect also for the NL West, but for the Giants overtaking the D-Backs for third on the last day. Thw worst divisions were the AL West and NL Central, with 6 off for each.
My last-place picks were disappointing. I picked all 3 of the sick franchises (Rays, Marlins, & A's) for last, but they all did better. I also made an idiosyncratic pick of the Cardinals for last, based on no off-season improvement, but they finished ahead of the woeful Pirates. The Marlins surely were the most surprising team in 2025, finishing third in the NL East, 13 games ahead of the last-place Nationals, and only 4 games behind the 2nd-place Mets.
And now for 2026.
AL East: Blue Jays, Yankees, Red Sox, Rays, Orioles
The Blue Jays seem committed to excellence, so I pick them to repeat. I refuse to pick the Rays for last again, as historically they have usually done better than expected. The Orioles have improved but still may finish last in the strong AL East. They may well become only the fourth team to ever finish last with a .500 or better win rate, after the 1987 Brewers, 2005 Nationals, and 2023 Yankees.
AL Central: Tigers, Guardians, Royals, Twins, White Sox
The Tigers were only one game out of first last year, so I have to pick them over my Guardians. The Tigers' strong starting pitching staff gives them good chances this year for post-season success. The White Sox were ten games out of fourth, so they seem to be destined for the basement again this year.
Al West: Mariners, Astros, Rangers, A's, Angels
The Mariners surprised last year by winning the division over the cheating Astros, and there is no reason they can't do it again this year. I feel sorry for Mike Trout, whose Angels have made the playoffs only once during his career, and they were swept 3-0 the one time they did. He deserves better.
NL East: Phillies, Mets, Braves, Marlins, Nationals
The Phillies won the division last year by 13 games, and seem poised to do it again, with an owner committed to winning. The Nationals finished last by 10 games, and should repeat.
NL Central: Cubs, Brewers, Reds. Cardinals, Pirates
My biggest mistake last year was picking the Brewers third. I can't pick against the Cubs, one of my favorite teams, so I'm going with the Brewers for second this year. The Pirates seem destined for last place again, and with an attendance of the fifth-lowest in MLB they are certainly a sick franchise.
NL West: Dodgers, Padres, Giants, Diamondbacks, Rockies
I so want to pick the Psdres over the Dodgers for first, but I can't bring myself to do it. I hope I'm wrong. The Dodgers made a huge blunder in signig Kyle Tucker for $240M for four years. Tucker has led his league only one time in any category, when had 112 RBI in 2023. A Cubs staffer commented that in the clubhouse Tucker "checks his phone more than he checks the scouting report. He has all the talent in the world, but the motor? It's not there." The Rockies had the worst record in all of MLB last year with only 43 wins, but still drew 2.4 miilion fans, good for 16th in MLB. Kudos to their loyal fans! The Giants are enthused about their new manager, the only manager to ever jump from the college ranks directly into an MLB manager's position. The players like his hands-on approach in contrast to the typical big-league manager approach.
